Conquer the Web

We Test, Synthesize and Share the Latest Internet Marketing Tactics and Strategies to Help You Better Run Your Online Business

200K People">Case Study: We Test Out Frank Kern’s Mass Control Marketing on 200K People

February 10th, 2008 by Vishen Lakhiani Read more about Email Marketing

Frank Kern’s Mass Con­trol mar­ket­ing was one of the best prod­uct launchs I’ve seen in Inter­net Mar­ket­ing his­tory. His videos were bril­liant but can the idea of “build­ing a rela­tion­ship with your list” really be that big a profit multiplier?

Our lab put the idea to the test and here’s the result. Now this is not meant to be an endorse­ment of Mass Con­trol Mar­ket­ing — the prod­uct is off the shelves. But hope­fully, you will learn a ton from read­ing this post and observ­ing the exper­i­ment we did.

The idea itself, is quite simple.

Peo­ple get on email to see what’s new with their friends and col­leagues. Peo­ple do not check their inboxes to shop. The ‘frame of mind’ they’re in is about com­mu­ni­cat­ing with friends.

Yet most list own­ers send out annoy­ing, salesly crap that their sub­scribers have no desire to read. There’s a frame of mind mis­match here. You’re try­ing to sell to peo­ple who are seek­ing a com­pletely dif­fer­ent expe­ri­ence from email. And this is why open rates and CTRs in emails have been falling for years.

So Kern’s advice is sim­ple. Build a rela­tion­ship with your list. Treat them as a ‘friend’ and write to them in the lan­guage and style they would expect from a friend or acquaintance.

The Exper­i­ment

We own a site that has a sub­scriber base of 200K. A bi-weekly newslet­ter goes out to this base. The promo pat­tern looks like this: The newslet­ter con­tains a short announce­ment of a spe­cial offer valid for 5 days. Then, just before the 5 days are up, the sub­scribers get a reminder email reaf­firm­ing the offer and remind­ing them of the promo end date com­ing up.

We took our reg­u­lar reminder email (below) and swapped it with an email inspired by Frank Kern’s lessons.

Email 1: Reg­u­lar Reminder Email

Sub­ject: {FIRSTNAME}, a Spe­cial Reminder

Hi {FIRSTNAME}

This is just a quick reminder..

The XXXXXXX Promo we told you about ends
Tomor­row Feb 5 2008

We’d like to invite you to take part in this promo and
mas­ter more advanced XXXX tech­niques — those that make up
the core of the XXXXX Product.

It’s going to take you miles beyond what you’ve stud­ied so
far…

In case you missed the first email, here’s the deal..

You had down­loaded our com­pli­men­tary XXXXX
Train­ing Pro­gram from our web site on Dec 5 2007.

I hope you have enjoyed our pro­gram and that it helped you
become more aware of your true potential.

Yet, what you just stud­ied is only a frac­tion of what XXXX
involves…

So we have a Spe­cial Offer for you…

Visit the link below to see full details of this offer…

Full Details Here…
www.XXXX.com

This offer is only valid until Feb 5 2008

Go Ahead, View the Spe­cial Offer..

And Do Email Me if you Have Any Questions.

Sin­cerely
Rachel Curt,
Your Cus­tomer Com­mu­ni­ca­tions Man­ager
www.XXXXXXXXX.com

Email 2: Mass Con­trol Mar­ket­ing inspired Email

Sub­ject Line: {FIRSTNAME}! Rachel here, don’t for­get about it…

Hi {FIRSTNAME},

Rachel here. I just wanted to remind you that I have this super cool bonus sur­prise for you if you order th1s week (I sent the announce­ment in the newslet­ter… I hope you saw it!)

Why am I doing this? Well, I know this prod­uct really works and I want you to develop your­self as much as you can (I have been work­ing with {Prod­uct X} for a few years now and I have seen lots of incred­i­ble results… so lets say I know what I am talk­ing about!) Plus I like to spoil my cus­tomers and I have a lot of mate­r­ial to share any­way, so why not?

This link is only going to be avail­able until next Tues­day Feb­ru­ary 5th

Check it out here!

I hope you like my sur­prise I have cho­sen some awe­some mate­r­ial which I per­son­ally adore

Cheers!

Sin­cerely
Rachel Curt,
Your Cus­tomer Com­mu­ni­ca­tions Man­ager
www.XXXXXXXXX.com

The Results (Drum­roll Please!)

You’ll notice that the friendly email cuts away the usual sales mes­sage and instead makes the sub­scriber feel that they are being writ­ten to by an enthu­si­as­tic friend.

We expected pos­i­tive results — but not these kinds of results.

The friendly email beat the con­trol by approx­i­mately 250% per­cent more sales.

So this stuff does work. And as for us, we’re cut­ting back on salesly emails and invest­ing more time in build­ing a rela­tion­ship with our list.

PS — our pre­vi­ous post on Frank Kern and Mass Con­trol Mar­ket­ing is here.

Last 5 posts by

About the Author

Vishen Lakhiani Vishen is a co-founder of MindValley. Before MindValley, he was an exec in Silicon Valley and New York for several internet and technology firms. He turned bedroom entrepreneur at 27 and by the time he was 31 had founded 6 web businesses and never had to work a conventional job again.

Check out other posts by Vishen Lakhiani

If you want to see what's in the private lab...

Ask yourself... which part of your business would you most like to improve?

I can send you 7 tactics related to your specific needs, if you like.

You don't have to buy anything, just take it as a backstage pass into our private course.

Will it give you the solution you've been waiting for?

There's only one way to find out.

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

12 Responses to “Case Study: We Test Out Frank Kern’s Mass Control Marketing on 200K People”

  1. Weekend + Monday Roundup from 2/9/08 - 2/11/08 | semvironment

    […] Case Study: We Test Out Frank Kern’s Mass Con­trol Mar­ket­ing on 200K Peo­ple — A “must read” post from the week­end. I am a firm believer in build­ing a good relationship…this is a very small glimpse of the poten­tial this method has. […]

  2. Jason Conway

    hi Jason here,

    I just wanted to say thank you for this blog post­ing. I have received many an email about mass con­trol and if the above listed email changes are just a brief exam­ple of what is in the mass con­trol pack­age then I would have to say that it is extremely impressive.

    Just by read­ing the changes in the email exam­ples, I have already thought of some ideas about chang­ing the way in which I email about my jv events that I con­sis­tantly con­tribute to.

    Thank you again.

  3. Lee

    Interesting…and I don’t doubt your results one bit…but how does the MC approach dif­fer from the tra­di­tional “hey dude” style of email­ers we’ve seen for years?

  4. vishen

    Lee, I think the essence of what’s going on here is that the sec­ond email speaks to the reader as a friend and not a “per­son to sell too”. It’s the frame of mind the writer is in when com­pos­ing the email.

  5. Sandy

    This just proves there is noth­ing new under the sun.

    I first started in direct sales nearly 40 years ago. I was trained in a tech­nique called “The No Objec­tion Sale”

    Basi­cally you spent a large pro­por­tion of your call get­ting to know as much about your poten­tial cus­tomer as pos­si­ble, you asked lots of ques­tions to find out what they needed and what they wanted and then you closed your book and chat­ted to them like a friend.

    You then told them that you would go away and look at every­thing that was avail­able and return when you found out the best pos­si­ble prod­uct for them as a friend. You then con­firmed with them what they were look­ing for and returned a week later and pre­sented your find­ings in the man­ner of one friend to another.

    I fol­lowed this faith­fully and for five years had 100% sales to calls ratio.
    Unbe­liev­able, I hear you cry. Well it is gospel.

    How did it finally go pear shaped. The com­pany I worked for sold out to new own­ers who reck­oned they knew how to sell “prop­erly”. ” None of this two call nonsense!”

    I had pre­vi­ously earned more in a month in direct sales than I had as a senior man­ager in indus­try in 12 months.

    From the day I was told to fol­low the new sales style until I finally let two years later my sales to calls ratio fell from 100% to 23% and I barely made a living.

    I tell this tale because online direct sales has very much in com­mon with off line sales. Except on line sales is where off line sales was 20 years ago.

    So it is nice to see that some­one has finally realised that if you treat a poten­tial cus­tomer they way you would treat your best friend you get supe­rior sales results.

    Who would have believed that?

  6. Kim Stacey

    Bril­liant! I couldn’t agree more; build­ing rela­tion­ships always brings greater suc­cess. Our list mem­bers are highly respon­sive, because we cul­ti­vate rela­tion­ships with each of them. When they write with ques­tions, we respond quickly, with delight at the oppor­tu­nity to serve.
    Each of them knows we are deeply con­cerned about their suc­cess, and they can be con­fi­dent in that ‘sup­port­ive’ ele­ment in the relationship.

    I love that you’ve been able to quan­tify the obvi­ous ben­e­fit of rela­tion­ship mar­ket­ing in such a dra­matic way. Thank you!

  7. Clint Lenard

    Guys, I think what’s funny is this…

    This is so BASIC, but I believe that once you start mon­e­tiz­ing from your lists, you lose site on what works to keep peo­ple trust­ing you…

    I know that List Build­ing was one of the last things I learned in Inter­net Mar­ket­ing, and Mass Con­trol is just a sim­ple tac­tic that you’re taught in the begin­ning… yet, you com­pletely for­get about WHY those peo­ple will actu­ally pur­chase from YOU, anyway.

    When I was a Car Sales­man (sales asso­ciate), they wanted us to prac­ti­cally attack any “up” (some­one who walks onto the lot) and make sure they did NOT leave before the Sales Man­ager got their shot at them… I even­tu­ally got fired because I respected peo­ple and knew that they didn’t want to be treated as a Com­mis­sion, but rather a per­son. The vet­er­ans of that Busi­ness DO make money, the same way as the vets in this busi­ness… but they lose peo­ple on their way up.

    When I was fired from that lot, I ended up at another smaller deal­er­ship sell­ing USED cars… FOREIGN cars, and my old “leads” found me there and pur­chased from me. They still trusted me… I treated them as a human and not a commission.

    Unfor­tu­nately, too many peo­ple are wor­ried about the best months ever, rather than the best years down the road. ;-)

    I’m def­i­nitely not impressed with what I watched on Mass Con­trol. Does it work? Well, yeah! It’s com­pletely log­i­cal, but basic. It’s not magic. It’s not sci­ence… it’s sim­ple psychology.

    While we were being trained by ex-FBI agents who were teach­ing us what a Cus­tomer was really think­ing when they were rub­bing their ear lobes, scratch­ing their nose, the way they stood, etc… I was learn­ing about HOW TO TREAT THE CUSTOMER the right way… guys like Joe Girard were OLD SCHOOL and didn’t care about how cus­tomers acted… he cared about what they WANTED.

    A list is the same way as a set of leads… you can cold call all day, but where is it going to get you? Build a Rap­port, then send them what they’re look­ing for.

    It’s not expen­sive or too time con­sum­ing to give away your own Spe­cial Reports that WILL help the peo­ple on your list. They signed up because they’re look­ing to fix the prob­lem they have with _____. Give it to them, and don’t stop just because they haven’t pur­chased once, or haven’t pur­chased 100 times. If they’re on your list, treat them with respect and give them what they want.

    Mass Con­trol is just another prod­uct that you’ll waste money and time on, in the end, in my opinion.

    Clint

  8. Wendy

    Your exam­ple email is excel­lent. I’ve been notic­ing a few mar­keters try­ing to put Kern’s lessons into action. Some are suc­cess­ful, and oth­ers are com­ing off creepy.

    Yeah, creepy like the half-drunk, com­plete stranger who puts his arm around you at the bar when he asks if he can buy you a drink.

    Maybe they’ll get it with a lit­tle more prac­tice. But, do those half-drunk guys at the bar ever learn?

  9. Debi

    Kern is spot-on about folk’s email mind­set and how chang­ing your approach can change the qual­ity of your land­ing from bumpy to smooth as silk. Your email invit­ing me to this blog post is another good exam­ple… and look, I’m here… and I’m doing what you asked me to do… as a friend! ;-)

    Another thing about the #2 Email is that it makes me feel more as if the time I might spend inves­ti­gat­ing the offer is intended to ben­e­fit ME, rather than the sender. I receive these tome-like, salesy emails and just shake my head and hit Delete. Don’t these folks real­ize that if you’ll waste my time and/or atten­tion it only fol­lows that you’ll prob­a­bly waste my money, too? That hits on a cou­ple more Kern-nals of Wis­dom: 1) rise above the noise and be dif­fer­ent; and 2) help folks decide they want your stuff instead of con­vinc­ing them.

    Some of those Mass Con­trol tech­niques are the best thing since warm, fresh-out-the-oven, unsliced bread, don’t you think?

    Thanks for the invite!

    Debi

  10. Payal

    I had tried almost the same thing, writ­ing in a more friendly man­ner. Just for records the com­pany I work with is a man­u­fac­turer of Agri prod­ucts and I am work­ing in the Mar­ket­ing team.
    On and off we send these mail­ers to com­pa­nies in other coun­tries with our com­pa­nies intro­duc­tion, leave apart replies I hardly got any read receipts. Later I started writ­ing the same facts in a more friend­lier man­ner or so to say in the Mass Con­trol Mar­ket­ing man­ner, but then my boss did not approve of it and told me to stick to basics. Instead what I did was I changed the 1st para which is the key that decides if the buyer is going to read fur­ther or not and bang on I could see the change in the num­ber of hits and replies.

    Look­ing for­ward to learn loads of new things from you guys.

    Cheers,
    Payal Mulchandani

  11. G.Sreenivasa Rao

    I enjoyed the arti­cle. Now, inter­net peo­ple are talk­ing fun­da­men­tals. I felt happy to know the value of a small coher­ent list.

    Rela­tion­ship is a func­tion of two peo­ple, their expec­ta­tions, situation,needs, and capac­i­ties. It takes time to start, build and con­tinue rela­tion­ship. In any rela­tion­ship, both have to grow. Oth­er­wise, one find another inter­est­ing and stim­u­lat­ing partners.

    If some one writes really from heart, then peo­ple respond more favour­baly. How­ever, once again, the fun­da­men­tal aspect comes into pic­ture– the trust fac­tor. Can I trust my mar­ket­ing guru? He sees me( I have not seen many female gurus) as a present buyer or poten­tial buyer. How would I see him– he expects me to see him as a guru, expert etc, not a seller, although the inten­tion of sell­ing is there all the time.

    If I don’t trust my mar­keter, can I trust his mes­sage. Results are func­tion of many fac­tors, and how just one fac­tor takes away all the credit.

    If my mar­ket­ing guru is rich, why is he keep sell­ing dif­fer­ent prod­ucts to all peo­ple, includ­ing me? If my guru is really a guru, he thinks about me first, later him, and later the prod­uct or ser­vice. How many self labelled gurus gen­uinely think like that? I don’t have sta­tis­tics and I don’t feel many are out­right there.

    Lan­guage is just one part of the com­mu­ni­ca­tion. Now, we may get prod­ucts of Copy write like Frank Kern– using his own emails as exam­ples. One fine morn­ing, we might get the tem­plates, the soft­ware, the audio course etc.

    In trust build­ing, actions count more. Chang­ing the expec­ta­tions count more. One mem­ber of the rela­tion­ship should be more will­ing, open and shar­ing. We all love real life sto­ries, the sor­rows, the fail­ures and vic­to­ries. Almost all inter­net mar­keters show me that they are suc­cess­ful, and earns in mil­lions. None of them really tell the pain, agony of fail­ure, learn­ing and get­ting once up and get­ting the sweet taste of money, recog­ni­tion and respect and above all sat­is­fac­tion of pub­lish­ing a book that with­stand the fads and time.

    In the end, we are all human beings. We respond to the per­son­al­ity more than the copy. If I like him, I like his mes­sage most of the time. If I don’t like his mes­sages, at some point I may respect him, and at some later point of time, I may even hate it.

    Many of the gurus are not really inter­ested about the world also. Some of them give offers for 12/24 hours– to increase the so called urgency– and by the time some one in India opens the mail, the offer is gone. I could not under­stand one thing– is is just plain igno­rance or I don’t care atti­tude because I have many mem­bers in my list. The ulti­mate test is– How one treats one who is far and entirely dif­fer­ent from you?

  12. http://insideroutline.net

    Frank is great and I have read alot about him. His ideas are amazing!

Leave a Reply